online gambling legal states

As the online gaming industry continues to grow and evolve, more states are considering legalizing online gambling. While some states have already made it legal, others continue to weigh the pros and cons of introducing online gambling in their jurisdictions. What is Online Gambling? Before diving into the specifics of legal states, let’s define what online gambling entails. Online gambling refers to the act of placing wagers or bets on various games or events through digital platforms. This can include online casinos, sports betting sites, poker rooms, and more.

  • Lucky Ace Palace
    new
    Luck&Luxury100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Cash King Palace
    Royal Wins100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Starlight Betting Lounge
    Celestial Bet100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Golden Spin Casino
    Luxury Play100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Silver Fox Slots
    Elegance+Fun100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Spin Palace Casino
    Win Big Now100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Royal Fortune Gaming
    Opulence & Thrills100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Diamond Crown Casino
    Opulence & Fun100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Lucky Ace Casino
    Luck&Luxury100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Opulent Play100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more

As the online gaming industry continues to grow and evolve, more states are considering legalizing online gambling. While some states have already made it legal, others continue to weigh the pros and cons of introducing online gambling in their jurisdictions.

What is Online Gambling?

Before diving into the specifics of legal states, let’s define what online gambling entails. Online gambling refers to the act of placing wagers or bets on various games or events through digital platforms. This can include online casinos, sports betting sites, poker rooms, and more.

Types of Online Gambling

There are several types of online gambling, including:

  • Casino games (e.g., slots, roulette, blackjack)
  • Sports betting
  • Poker tournaments
  • Bingo
  • Horse racing
  • Esports betting

Which States Have Legalized Online Gambling?

While federal laws prohibit online gambling in the United States, some states have taken it upon themselves to legalize and regulate this industry. Here are some of the states that have made online gambling legal:

1. New Jersey

New Jersey was one of the first states to introduce regulated online gaming. In 2013, Governor Chris Christie signed a bill allowing licensed casinos to offer online betting.

  • Online casino games (e.g., slots, blackjack, roulette)
  • Sports betting

2. Nevada

Nevada has long been a hub for land-based casinos and has since extended its reach to online gaming. In 2011, the state passed legislation permitting online poker.

  • Online poker tournaments
  • Casino games (e.g., slots, blackjack)

3. Delaware

Delaware became the second US state after Nevada to legalize online poker in 2012.

  • Online poker tournaments
  • Sports betting

4. Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania joined the ranks of states allowing online gaming with the passing of its own legislation in 2019.

  • Online casino games (e.g., slots, blackjack)
  • Sports betting

5. West Virginia

West Virginia followed suit by legalizing online sports betting in 2018 and then expanded to include online poker and casino games in 2020.

  • Online poker tournaments
  • Casino games (e.g., slots, blackjack)
  • Sports betting

Other States Considering Online Gambling

While the above-mentioned states have taken a step towards regulating online gaming, many others are still evaluating the pros and cons. Some of these include:

California

California has been contemplating allowing tribal casinos to offer online sports betting.

Florida

Florida has introduced legislation to permit online sports betting, although it’s still pending approval.

Regulation and Security Concerns

While some states have moved towards legalizing online gambling, there remain concerns regarding regulation and security. Online gaming operators must adhere to strict guidelines to ensure fair play and protect player data.

  • Compliance with licensing requirements
  • Protection of player personal information and funds
  • Prevention of money laundering and other illicit activities

As the world becomes increasingly digital, more states are warming up to the idea of regulating online gambling. While there are legitimate concerns about security and regulation, the potential benefits for state coffers and job creation can’t be ignored.

In conclusion, the landscape of online gaming is constantly shifting as new states join the fray, but the core principles remain the same: fair play, responsible gaming practices, and robust regulation to protect all stakeholders involved.

top online gambling sites for 2023: best options & reviews

As the online gambling industry continues to grow, finding the best sites can be a daunting task. Whether you’re into sports betting, casino games, or poker, the sheer number of options can be overwhelming. To help you navigate this landscape, we’ve compiled a list of the top online gambling sites for 2023, complete with reviews and insights.

1. Betway

Overview

Betway is a well-established name in the online gambling world, offering a comprehensive platform for sports betting, casino games, and poker.

Key Features

  • Sports Betting: Extensive coverage of football, basketball, tennis, and more.
  • Casino Games: A vast selection of slots, table games, and live dealer options.
  • Poker: Regular tournaments and a user-friendly interface.

Pros

  • User-friendly interface
  • Excellent customer support
  • Wide variety of games and betting options

Cons

  • Limited availability in some regions

2. 888 Casino

Overview

888 Casino is a leading online casino known for its high-quality games and generous bonuses.

Key Features

  • Slots: Hundreds of slot games, including progressive jackpots.
  • Table Games: Classic games like blackjack, roulette, and baccarat.
  • Live Casino: Real-time games with live dealers.

Pros

  • Generous welcome bonuses
  • High-quality games from top providers
  • Secure and reliable platform

Cons

  • Limited sports betting options

3. William Hill

Overview

William Hill is a giant in the sports betting industry, offering a robust platform for both sports and casino enthusiasts.

Key Features

  • Sports Betting: Comprehensive coverage of major sports events.
  • Casino: A wide range of slots, table games, and live casino options.
  • Poker: Regular tournaments and a dedicated poker room.

Pros

  • Extensive sports betting options
  • High-quality casino games
  • Strong reputation and reliability

Cons

  • Interface can be overwhelming for new users

4. LeoVegas

Overview

LeoVegas is known for its mobile-first approach, offering a seamless gambling experience on both desktop and mobile devices.

Key Features

  • Mobile Compatibility: Optimized for mobile devices.
  • Casino Games: A vast selection of slots, table games, and live dealer options.
  • Sports Betting: Good coverage of major sports events.

Pros

  • Excellent mobile experience
  • Fast and reliable platform
  • Generous bonuses and promotions

Cons

  • Limited availability in some countries

5. Bet365

Overview

Bet365 is a powerhouse in the online gambling industry, offering a comprehensive platform for sports betting, casino games, and more.

Key Features

  • Sports Betting: Extensive coverage of football, basketball, tennis, and more.
  • Casino Games: A wide range of slots, table games, and live dealer options.
  • Live Streaming: Watch live sports events directly on the platform.

Pros

  • Comprehensive sports betting options
  • High-quality live streaming
  • User-friendly interface

Cons

  • Limited availability in some regions

Choosing the right online gambling site depends on your preferences and needs. Whether you’re a sports enthusiast, a casino lover, or a poker player, the sites listed above offer a high-quality gambling experience. Always remember to gamble responsibly and choose a site that is licensed and regulated to ensure a safe and fair experience.

best online gambling apps for real money: top picks & reviews

In the digital age, online gambling has become increasingly popular, offering convenience and a wide variety of games. Whether you’re into sports betting, casino games, or poker, there’s an app for that. Here, we review the best online gambling apps for real money, providing you with top picks and detailed insights to help you make an informed choice.

1. Bet365

Overview

Bet365 is a renowned name in the online gambling industry, offering a comprehensive platform for sports betting, casino games, and more.

Features

  • Sports Betting: Extensive coverage of sports events worldwide.
  • Live Streaming: Watch live sports events directly on the app.
  • Casino Games: A vast selection of slots, table games, and live dealer options.
  • User Interface: Intuitive and easy to navigate.

Pros

  • Wide range of betting options.
  • High-quality live streaming.
  • Excellent customer support.

Cons

  • Limited availability in some regions.

2. DraftKings

Overview

DraftKings is a leading platform for daily fantasy sports and sports betting, offering a robust app for real money gambling.

Features

  • Daily Fantasy Sports: Compete in daily and weekly contests.
  • Sports Betting: Bet on a variety of sports, including football, basketball, and more.
  • Casino: Access to slots, table games, and live dealer games.
  • Promotions: Regular bonuses and promotions.

Pros

  • User-friendly interface.
  • Extensive sports betting options.
  • Generous promotions.

Cons

  • Limited casino game selection compared to other apps.

3. Betway

Overview

Betway is a global online gambling company known for its sports betting and casino offerings.

Features

  • Sports Betting: Comprehensive coverage of major sports.
  • Live Betting: Bet on events as they happen.
  • Casino: Wide range of slots, table games, and live dealer options.
  • Esports: Bet on popular esports tournaments.

Pros

  • Strong focus on esports.
  • High-quality live betting platform.
  • Excellent mobile app.

Cons

  • Customer support can be slow at times.

4. 888 Casino

Overview

888 Casino is a premier online casino app offering a wide variety of games and a seamless gambling experience.

Features

  • Slots: Hundreds of slot games, including progressive jackpots.
  • Table Games: Classic games like blackjack, roulette, and baccarat.
  • Live Dealer: High-quality live dealer games.
  • Promotions: Regular bonuses and promotions.

Pros

  • Extensive game selection.
  • High-quality live dealer games.
  • Generous welcome bonuses.

Cons

  • Limited sports betting options.

5. FanDuel

Overview

FanDuel is a popular platform for daily fantasy sports and sports betting, offering a user-friendly app for real money gambling.

Features

  • Daily Fantasy Sports: Compete in daily and weekly contests.
  • Sports Betting: Bet on a variety of sports, including football, basketball, and more.
  • Casino: Access to slots, table games, and live dealer games.
  • Promotions: Regular bonuses and promotions.

Pros

  • User-friendly interface.
  • Extensive sports betting options.
  • Generous promotions.

Cons

  • Limited casino game selection compared to other apps.

Choosing the best online gambling app for real money depends on your preferences and the types of games you enjoy. Whether you’re into sports betting, casino games, or daily fantasy sports, the apps reviewed above offer a high-quality gambling experience with a variety of features and promotions. Make sure to check the availability and regulations in your region before downloading any app. Happy gambling!

best gambling websites

In the vast world of online gambling, finding the best websites can be a daunting task. Whether you’re into sports betting, casino games, or poker, the right platform can make all the difference. Here, we’ve curated a list of the best gambling websites to help you get started.

1. Bet365

Overview

Bet365 is a powerhouse in the online gambling industry, known for its comprehensive sportsbook and casino offerings.

Features

  • Sports Betting: Extensive coverage of football, basketball, tennis, and more.
  • Live Betting: Real-time betting on ongoing matches.
  • Casino: A wide range of slots, table games, and live dealer options.
  • Poker: Regular tournaments and a user-friendly interface.

Pros

  • User-friendly interface
  • Excellent customer support
  • High betting limits

Cons

  • Limited availability in some regions

2. 888 Casino

Overview

888 Casino is a veteran in the online casino space, offering a diverse range of games and a robust platform.

Features

  • Slots: Hundreds of slot games, including progressive jackpots.
  • Table Games: Classic games like blackjack, roulette, and baccarat.
  • Live Casino: Real-time dealer games with high-quality streaming.
  • Poker: Regular tournaments and a dedicated poker platform.

Pros

  • Trusted brand with a long history
  • Generous welcome bonuses
  • Mobile-friendly platform

Cons

  • Slightly slower withdrawal times compared to competitors

3. William Hill

Overview

William Hill is a well-established name in the gambling world, offering a comprehensive sportsbook and casino.

Features

  • Sports Betting: Extensive coverage of major sports events.
  • Live Betting: Real-time betting with in-play options.
  • Casino: A wide range of slots, table games, and live dealer options.
  • Poker: Regular tournaments and a dedicated poker room.

Pros

  • Extensive betting options
  • High betting limits
  • Excellent customer support

Cons

  • Interface can be overwhelming for new users

4. Betway

Overview

Betway is a popular choice for both sports betting and casino enthusiasts, known for its user-friendly platform.

Features

  • Sports Betting: Comprehensive coverage of football, basketball, and more.
  • Live Betting: Real-time betting with in-play options.
  • Casino: A wide range of slots, table games, and live dealer options.
  • Poker: Regular tournaments and a dedicated poker room.

Pros

  • User-friendly interface
  • Generous welcome bonuses
  • Mobile app available

Cons

  • Limited availability in some regions

5. LeoVegas

Overview

LeoVegas is a mobile-first gambling platform, offering a seamless experience across devices.

Features

  • Slots: Hundreds of slot games, including progressive jackpots.
  • Table Games: Classic games like blackjack, roulette, and baccarat.
  • Live Casino: Real-time dealer games with high-quality streaming.
  • Sports Betting: Coverage of major sports events.

Pros

  • Excellent mobile app
  • Fast withdrawals
  • Generous welcome bonuses

Cons

  • Limited sports betting options compared to competitors

Choosing the best gambling website depends on your specific needs and preferences. Whether you’re a sports enthusiast, a casino lover, or a poker player, the platforms listed above offer a variety of options to suit your gambling style. Always remember to gamble responsibly and within your means.

Frequently Questions

How does online gambling operate within the legal framework of India?

Online gambling in India operates under a complex legal framework, varying by state. The Public Gambling Act of 1867 is the primary legislation, but it does not explicitly address online gambling. States like Goa, Sikkim, and Daman have legalized certain forms of online gambling, including casinos and sports betting. However, other states prohibit it. The Supreme Court has allowed states to regulate gambling activities. Operators must comply with local laws, obtain necessary licenses, and ensure responsible gambling practices. Despite the legal ambiguity, the online gambling market in India is growing, driven by technological advancements and changing consumer preferences.

What Are the Legal Statuses of Gambling Sites in India?

The legal status of gambling sites in India varies by state. While the Public Gambling Act of 1867 is the central law, it allows states to regulate gambling activities. Currently, states like Goa, Sikkim, and Daman permit land-based casinos, and online gambling is legal in some form in Sikkim and Nagaland. Sikkim even issues licenses for online gambling. However, most states prohibit online gambling, leading to a patchwork of regulations. It's crucial for operators and players to understand the specific laws of their state to avoid legal repercussions.

 

What are the current online gambling laws in my country?

The current online gambling laws in your country depend on where you reside. In the United States, for example, online gambling is regulated at the state level, with some states allowing various forms of online gambling while others prohibit it. In the UK, online gambling is legal and regulated by the UK Gambling Commission. In Canada, online gambling is legal but regulated provincially. To find specific laws for your country, consult your local government or legal resources. Always ensure you are aware of and comply with the laws in your jurisdiction to avoid legal issues.

Is Online Gambling Legal in the United States?

The legality of online gambling in the United States varies by state. As of now, states like New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Nevada have legalized and regulated online gambling, including casino games, poker, and sports betting. However, other states have yet to legalize it or have specific restrictions. Federal law, such as the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA) of 2006, also plays a role in regulating online gambling activities. It's crucial for players to check their local laws and regulations before engaging in online gambling to ensure compliance and avoid legal issues.

What are the current online gambling laws in my country?

The current online gambling laws in your country depend on where you reside. In the United States, for example, online gambling is regulated at the state level, with some states allowing various forms of online gambling while others prohibit it. In the UK, online gambling is legal and regulated by the UK Gambling Commission. In Canada, online gambling is legal but regulated provincially. To find specific laws for your country, consult your local government or legal resources. Always ensure you are aware of and comply with the laws in your jurisdiction to avoid legal issues.